1565 County Rd 517, Allamuchy Township, NJ 07820
Panther Valley Deli & bagel
See Menu

Allamuchy and Hackettstown's Best Bagel & Deli

Order Now

Boar's Head
Deli Counter

Boar’s Head deli meats are crafted with premium cuts, bold flavor, and high-quality ingredients for the perfect sandwich experience. From slow-roasted turkey and savory roast beef to classic Italian favorites, every slice delivers rich flavor and exceptional freshness

View Menu

Visit Us

Mon-Sun 6am – 2pm

Located In The Rear Of The Panther Valley Mall

Directions
Hero 1

Our Story

Panther Valley Bagel & Deli opened in January 2026 with a simple goal: to give Allamuchy Township a neighborhood breakfast and lunch spot worth coming back to every single day. Our bagels are made fresh daily, build every sandwich with care, and greet every guest with a warm smile. We are proud to serve the families, commuters, and neighbors of Panther Valley and the greater Warren County community.
Learn More
Hero 2

Fan Favorites

The Italian

Imported meats, sharp provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and house dressing on a roll.

The Belly Buster

Taylor ham, bacon, savory sausage, eggs, potatoes, and cheese on a roll.

The Morning Panther

Brisket, Taylor ham, bacon, eggs, and cheese.

See Menu

Catering For The Whole Office

Planning a breakfast meeting, office lunch, or family celebration? Panther Valley Bagel & Deli brings fresh, made-with-care food right to your event. From signature bagel spreads to hearty deli sandwich trays, our catering menu is built to impress. We work with you to customize every order based on your group size and preferences. Proudly serving Hackettstown, Allamuchy Township, and all of Warren County. Fill out our inquiry form to start planning today.
Learn More

Order Online

Your favorite bagels and deli sandwiches are just a few taps away. With Panther Valley Bagel & Deli online ordering, you can browse our full menu, customize your meal, and schedule a pickup in minutes. Powered by SkyTab, our system is fast, easy, and built for busy mornings. Whether you are grabbing breakfast before work or planning a lunch run, order ahead and skip the wait. Tap the button below to get started.

Gallery

Happy Customers

"I don’t usually leave reviews but!!! I stopped here to charge my car and walked around to check the mall out and bumped into this place and I’m SOOOOOOO glad that I decided to buy this bagel! I think it’s the best bagel in the area!! And I have tried a couple places but wow this one it’s amazing!"

Scarlet T.

"Newly renovated with new owners and tons of options to choose from. The Boar’s Head meats are top-notch, and the staff is incredibly friendly. This place is an absolute gem of a deli. Fresh, stacked sandwiches, big flavors, zero disappointment. Do yourself a favor and eat here."

FamilyMan - Allamuchy, NJ

"First time here and I’ll definitely be back since the new ownership. Warm and welcoming when walking in. My husband got a breakfast burrito and I got the southwest burrito. Super good. Mac salad is delicious as well. Not a coffee fan but my husband said the flavored coffee is delicious. Kind people working. Highly recommend"

Kristyn D. Warren County, NJ

Contact us

Name

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Join Our Team

Inquire Now